Ancient-Spooks update with Egyptian text: Great Hymn to Aten

Hi LOL, I got the impression that the "Saturn" stuff has a large following simply because it's "cool" mysticism, but there are really no arguments behind it.

Yes, I am also not impressed by Miles' criticism of Velikovsky & Talbott, but that's because he has still adopted their "alien origins" nonsense. Without any arguments, just like Velikovsky & Talbott have no arguments. I'd rate Miles "Saturn" paper as worst of all times. I have read Talbott's "Saturn Myth", and it was really "complete garbage", just like Miles said. It's just randomly strung together citations of various myths, mostly without even a hint of how they'd relate to Saturn.

Yes, words can be "interpreted" in countless ways, if you don't need verification. So there will always be many mysticist gurus, who just pick a few words, "reinterpret" them into something "cool", without arguments or verification, and will have a large instant following.

That's why I don't "interpret" individual words. I match them to similar words, using only official meanings found in the dictionaries. That only allows a handful of meaningful choices. Then I match entire sentences and long texts. The resulting encrypted text has to be continuous and also has to make sense, using only the straightforward dictionary translations. It's almost impossible to get a consistent second meaning that way, unless the authors wrote it into the text. As proof, ask yourself this: Why have none of the studied, well-funded mainstream & alternative "authorities" of all ages ever used this method to get a secret meaning out of these texts, one that'd suit their "cool" theories and please their followers? It's impossible, that's why.

My research is also based purely on logical & realistic assumptions: Namely, that powerful people can be corrupt and use their power for deception. My research also answers meaningful questions, that cannot be answered in any other way: Why is our world so full of deception? Why do the elites use so many religious references, and are at the same time anti-religious? Where does the apparent "Jewish" influence & power come from? I can explain it all, because my decryptions show that ancient rulers were already deceivers, who they didn't believe in religion, and that much of the world was colonized from Phoenicia. What questions are explained by "alien origins"? None.

Case in point is the Great Hymn to Aten: Here, "Aten" is described as rising when people wake up, being in the sky during the day, setting when people go to sleep, making plants grow, and also as shining with rays. So, a translation as "sun" makes total sense. My decryption as "secrecy" also makes sense, and can be verified through the many other words that mean "secret" & "cover", some even literally. A translation as "Saturn" makes no sense at all, there's no argument or verification to it, not in this text, and not anywhere else.

I assume that's intentional.  He knows there is already a cottage industry pushing alien theories, and doesn't feel the need to join in.  He knows the evidence isn't conclusive and would rather speculate than persuade.  I don't see the harm in that.  I'll take that over, say, his calculus papers where he tries and fails miserably to write mathematical proofs of his conjectures.  THAT stuff is embarrassing.